Next Michigan AD: 'It depends' on coach-student sexual relationships
· Yahoo Sports
Trev Alberts, who is expected to be named the University of Michigan's next athletic director, said "it depends" when asked during a December deposition whether college coaches should ever have sexual relationships with student-athletes, despite a University of Nebraska-Lincoln policy prohibiting such relationships.
Visit bettingx.bond for more information.
Alberts gave the testimony during the deposition as a defendant in an ongoing federal lawsuit alleging that he and other University of Nebraska-Lincoln officials mishandled a sexual relationship between an associate women's basketball coach and a player during his tenure as athletic director.
The lawsuit was filed by Ashley Scoggin, a former Nebraska women's basketball player. She claimed the university didn't protect her and failed to properly investigate how she, as a student-athlete, was "groomed" by associate women's basketball coach Chuck Love to carry on a secret relationship. Alberts is named as a defendant, along with head coach Amy Williams, Love and Nebraska's Board of Regents.
In a response to Scoggin's lawsuit, attorneys for Williams, Alberts and the university denied her allegations and said the defendants were unaware of the details of the relationship until she filed a Title IX complaint in March 2022.
The lawsuit also alleges Alberts failed to question Williams' decision to remove Scoggin from the team or investigate whether Love had relationships with other students and whether Williams knew about them. It further alleges he failed to require employee training or clarify athletic department policies prohibiting sexual relationships between coaches and student-athletes.
The lawsuit also alleges Alberts encouraged Scoggin to leave Nebraska and allowed Love to resign voluntarily.
Attorneys for Scoggin declined to comment. Messages were left with Alberts and attorneys for him and the university. Nebraska's Senior Director of Communications Cara Pesek declined to comment and said the university did not comment on pending litigation.
Expert questions Alberts' comments as Michigan faces scrutiny
Nellie Drew, the director of the Center for the Advancement of Sport at the University at Buffalo School of Law, said Alberts' comments were "flabbergasting." Understanding the university's and federal government's policies regarding Title IX and sexual harassment are a "core component" of an athletic director's job, she said.
"There's a difference between not being aware of something happening and not being aware of what you need to be doing as a mandatory reporter," Drew said. "He was (at the Nebraska system) for a long time, should’ve been doing mandatory training. ... He signs off on annual affirmations that the university is in compliance."
Alberts' answers to two depositions from December and February were first reported by David Covucci of FOIAball.
Alberts is expected to succeed Michigan Athletic Director Warde Manuel, who has faced his own questions about oversight of coaches and knowledge of inappropriate relationships happening within the department, after he fired former head football coach Sherrone Moore in December 2025 for his inappropriate relationship with his assistant, Paige Shiver.
After his firing, Moore was arrested after barging into Shiver's residence and threatening her. This incident, along with how Moore's firing was handled, caused the university to retain attorneys with the Chicago-based law firm Jenner & Block, who were originally hired to investigate Moore's relationship with Shiver. The university authorized the attorneys to expand their investigation to look at the culture of the Athletic Department.
Although Manuel, who's ultimately charged with the oversight of the department, was not fired as a result of the investigation, he told UM President Domenico Grasso he'd like to step down at the end of the year, shortly before a summary of the review's results was released.
Drew said she would be surprised if conversations about his active lawsuit weren't happening among the Michigan regents and administration. However, in the complicated world of college athletics, lawsuits involving athletic directors are common.
But at a place like Michigan, especially with their recent controversies surrounding oversight and accountability, questions needed to be asked, she said.
"One hopes the trustees would be seeking someone who doesn’t have these things in their background," she said.
Alberts answered questions on Title IX, coach-student relationships
Alberts was questioned by one of Scoggin's attorneys, Maren Chaloupka. The first deposition lasted nearly four hours and the second lasted just over three hours.
Chaloupka asked Alberts if he believed college coaches should never have sex with student-athletes, as the university had a policy forbidding relationships between faculty and students, which included those in coaching positions. Alberts responded that he "didn't know the answer to that" and then said "it depends" and there was "nuance" because COVID eligibility rules meant some students were "25, 26 years old," and some of the coaches could be "27, 28."
"Clearly, if there is a — if there is an assumption or if we think that's happening, that's when we are not encouraged, but trained to report it to the experts," Alberts said in the deposition. "We are not experts in this. I'm not an expert in that area. And I don't make that judgment."
Aaron Hernandez, the director of the National Sports Law Institute at Marquette University, said Alberts' answer was "problematic."
"The way to answer a question like that is 'We don’t want our coaches doing that,'" Hernandez said. "The fact that he danced around it is probably not the route Michigan wants to go with given their own situation."
Nebraska's policy on relationships explicitly prohibits relationships between staff and students. It states: "faculty or staff members are prohibited from engaging in any romantic relationship with an undergraduate student, regardless of whether the faculty or staff member has any supervisory or evaluative authority over that student."
Barbara Osborne, a professor of legal issues in college athletics and NCAA governance and compliance at the University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill, said policies like Nebraska's are generally best practice and common in higher education.
"It’s very hard to draw a line between what is welcome and what is coercive," she said. "Most schools draw a line saying 'No, you can’t at all.' ... It's super important for anyone working in higher education to know the policy of the institution."
Alberts said cases were handed over to the Title IX office and the Office of General Counsel and were not handled by the athletic department.
Alberts also said he didn't "get involved" or "try to monitor" relationships in the department.
"If something happens, and it becomes — and we think maybe we should — we forward it to the Title IX office, and we forward it to the lawyers," he said.
Hernandez said handing cases over to the Title IX office was best practice, but Alberts had an "affirmative obligation to monitor and control the culture of the department."
"You have to be a leader and say 'You’re not doing that here' (to the people in the department)," Hernandez said.
When asked if coaches pursuing players for a sexual relationship was "predatory," Alberts said he didn't feel comfortable answering the question because he didn't understand what Chaloupka was asking him. When she said she credited him with understanding his role as AD of a major program, he said that maybe she was "crediting me too much," before agreeing it would be a predatory act.
Many ADs and other department administrators don't know exactly what Title IX requires, Osborne said.
"Research shows a lot of ADs and administration would not pass a Title IX test, if that was a thing," she said. "That's why it's important to have strong policies that are easily available and have the training so those in leadership at every level know what the policies are. Institutions need consistency."
.oembed-frame {width:100%;height:100%;margin:0;border:0;}
Want to comment on this story? Become a subscriber today. Click here.
This article originally appeared on The Detroit News: Next Michigan AD: 'It depends' on coach-student sexual relationships