Four A's Prospects Facing 40-Man Decisions

· Yahoo Sports

Major League Baseball's Rule 5 deadline is on Tuesday, November 17 at 3:00 p.m. (PT), which will leave the Athletics' new front office with some of its first big decisions of the winter. The A's 40-man roster is currently full, meaning that any player added to the roster will lead to another player being designated for assignment to clear space. 

The four players who are in play to be added to the A's 40-man roster on Tuesday are catcher Cole Conn, and right-handed pitchers Kenya Huggins, Nathan Dettmer, and Jackson Finley. MLB Pipeline has each of them ranked in the bottom third of the A's top-30, with Conn at No. 21, Huggins ranking No. 23, Dettmer right behind him at No. 24, and Finley at No. 27.

Visit sport-tr.bet for more information.

Conn, 25, was selected by the A's in the 12th round of the 2023 MLB Draft and just put together his best season in the minors, posting a .286 average with a .389 OBP and a cumulative 116 wRC+ split between Double-A (70 games) and Triple-A (36 games).

The A's could easily add him to the 40-man roster and put him in line to be the team's backup catcher in short order, or they could sign a veteran backstop and continue to let Conn develop at his own pace.

The third option would be to not protect him at all and hope for the best. The A's also have Davis Diaz, 23, who isn't Rule 5 eligible until next offseason and is in a similar place with his development, so leaving Conn unprotected comes with a built-in backup plan, if that's the route the front office decides to go.

Huggins was acquired by the A's in the Miguel Andujar trade in 2025, and while he posted a 6.63 ERA across 91 innings in Double-A, he also held a 4.22 FIP. He seemed to settle in once he switched to relief pitching, holding a 4.91 ERA in 20 appearances, and tossing another 10 ⅓ innings in the Arizona Fall League, racking up a 1.74 ERA with 13 strikeouts and five walks.

He's trending in the right direction, and seems to have responded to the challenge of performing in the AFL, which may have been enough to earn him a roster spot.

Dettmer, 24, is a former fifth-round pick, and he touched four levels of the A's organization (A to Triple-A) in 2026. Across 120 ⅓ innings he posted a 4.86 ERA (4.42 FIP) with a 22.3% strikeout rate and a 6.5% walk rate. He's a ground-ball pitcher with a terrific walk rate — two skills the A's are after this winter. That could be enough to earn him a roster spot. 

Finally, there is Jackson Finley, who posted a 2.77 ERA (3.70 FIP) in 12 Double-A starts spanning 48 ⅔ innings. In two brief Triple-A starts, Finley went just seven innings and gave up eight earned runs and three home runs, walking six and striking out six. That could be enough to give an opposing team pause before selecting him in the Rule 5 Draft, and then putting him onto their big-league roster. 

Read full story at source